Phulgenda Sinha pretty much decimates the Bhagavad Gita, cutting it down from verses to just Patanjali’s Yoga Sutra is similarly culled. The Gita as it was: Rediscovering the Original Bhagavadgita. Front Cover. Phulgenda Sinha. Open Court, – Religion – pages. The Gita as it was: rediscovering the original Bhagavadgita. Front Cover. Phulgenda Sinha. Open Court, – Religion – pages.

Author: Brajinn Turisar
Country: Papua New Guinea
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Automotive
Published (Last): 28 July 2004
Pages: 456
PDF File Size: 8.70 Mb
ePub File Size: 9.6 Mb
ISBN: 516-2-49100-491-7
Downloads: 82751
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Faulkree

Grimmly 14 September at Shankaracharya, in particular, is named and shamed. Great stuff isn’t it Maya, think he gets a bit carried away at times but it’s fun all the same and I think the central premiss holds up.

They all put the date of Gita as between B. In Rig Veda 1. Gita in the vulgate form is still strongly Sankhya, and Yoga philosophies, especially the bhakti yoga.

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

The Gita as It Was: Rediscovering the Original Bhagavadgita by Phulgenda Sinha

In this book, the author observes the following: The second bird is the Paramatman, an aspect of God who accompanies every living being in the heart while she remains in the material world. Sinha seems on strong ground phulgenca. He claims that the original Gita written by sage Vyasa at about B. Same with the Gita, keep it to the 84 verses Sinha mentions and you have Samkhya and Yoga add the rest as we have it today and all of that seems to become completely undermined Note the new Blog Url.


The Gita as it Was : Phulgenda Sinha :

Should be coming soon, love that it sounds like a novel, the other book was boring me a little. Refresh and try again.

Just got it in today. Pattabhi Jois memorial 1 Sri K. And in Rig Veda 1. Yinzadi marked it as to-read Aug 23, Aaditya marked it as to-read Jun 10, Santhosh Sundararaman rated it really liked it Jan 05, Open Preview See a Problem? Grimmly 27 September at Grimm have a great weekend with Richard.

Phulgenda Sinha’s ‘The Gita as it was’. David Melik rated it really liked it Nov 02, Wish I’d phugenda Ramaswami more on this. Grace rated it it was ok Nov 28, I will try to read it next weekend, I would try this weekend but I decided I need to re-read a lot of materials for classes.

The Gita as it Was : Discovering the Original Bhagavadgita

Excellent idea, when is that movie coming out? Pattabhi Jois 1 Ashtanga after fifty 1 Ashtanga and addiction 1 ashtanga and age 2 ashtanga and ageing 4 Ashtanga and Boredom 1 Ashtanga and Diet 1 Ashtanga and Drug Addiction 1 Ashtanga and eating 1 Ashtanga and fun 1 Ashtanga and kumbhaka 1 Ashtanga and losing weight 1 Ashtanga and menstruation 1 Ashtanga and pregnancy 1 Ashtanga and recovery 1 Ashtanga and Socrates 1 Ashtanga and Sweat 1 Ashtanga and the wrist 1 Ashtanga and Vinyasa krama yoga Maidenhead 1 Ashtanga and Weight lost 1 Ashtanga and Zen 2 Ashtanga as it was 2 Ashtanga assists 1 Ashtanga assists.

Jason marked it as to-read Dec 15, The Mahabharata was supposedly only verses not thewe have now. Mountainking marked it as to-read Jun 06, He argues that much of the ideological conflicts in Gita are due to interpolation that occurred during the revival of Brahmanism. Arwin rated it it was amazing Nov 14, Oh that was the Elaide book that came, yeah looked heavier haven’t ordered it yet, no wonder you put it to one side.


Newer Post Older Post Home.

No trivia or quizzes yet. Who sung the song of God The author makes a provocative suggestion that Bhagavad-Gita is highly interpolated. Nanjundaswami Malavalli marked it as to-read Mar 21, Karuna marked it as to-read Mar 29, This one you should be able to read. Hari Yathirajulu marked it as to-read Oct 10, Pradeep Akella added it Jul 29, This observation certainly argues against interpolation by Shankara.

Why would Patanjali keep Samkhya’s 25 categories and then go ahead and add a 26th. Ur-zababa rated it it was amazing Nov 15, The original Gita had 84 verses and began at verse 28 of chapter 1 and covers the first three chapters; the last 15 chapters of Gita and few verses in the first three chapters were introduced to create a link with Vedanta and monotheism; the original Gita was altered during the time of Brahmanical revivalism around A. Gnanashakher marked it as to-read Sep 09, Pattabhi Jois 3 Sri k.

Raghu Sreenivasan marked it as to-read Jul 14, Had enough philosophy for the day week off for a bath with ‘The making gitq a poem’. In this book he postulates that the success of Sankhya and Yoga philosophies in the teachings of Buddhism and Jainism caused fear among Vedic Brahmans that the Vedic practices will be forgotten and lost.